Monroe County property taxes and STAR, explained for buyers

How the bills work

First, confirm where the parcel actually sits. A “Rochester, NY” mailing address covers big parts of Greece, Gates, Brighton, Irondequoit and other towns. Your tax bills follow the municipality, not the post office.

Dates are from the City and Monroe County, and they can shift a day when a deadline lands on a weekend. Your own town’s receiver of taxes has the exact schedule. If the home is inside a village, like Pittsford, Fairport or Spencerport, expect a village tax bill too. Ask the village clerk when it comes.

Why the seller’s bill isn’t yours

The tax number in a listing or on the seller’s last bill is a starting point, not your number. Here’s why it changes when you buy.

1. Exemptions belong to the owner, not the house

   Senior citizens, veterans, people with disabilities and others can qualify for property tax exemptions. Those are based on the owner. When the seller leaves, their exemptions leave with them.

2. The seller’s STAR doesn’t transfer

   If the seller has the STAR exemption, it comes off when the home changes hands. You register for your own STAR credit, which comes as a check from the state instead of a reduction on the bill.

3. Assessments can change

   Towns and the City update assessments, sometimes through a full reassessment. A home assessed years ago can look cheap to own until the next one. Ask what the current assessment is and whether a reassessment is coming.

4. Tax rates change every year

   Each taxing body sets its own rate each year. Last year’s bill times this year’s rate is closer, but still an estimate.

Where to look up a parcel’s taxes and assessment

• Monroe County Real Property Portal: assessment, property details and tax information for parcels across the county.
• City of Rochester property information: for city parcels, the City’s portal shows tax bills and payment history.
• Your town assessor: each town has its own assessor and receiver of taxes. Monroe County keeps a contact list for every one.
• Tax rate tables: Monroe County publishes current town, county, village and school tax rates if you want to check the math.

Look up the exact parcel, not a neighbor’s. Two homes on the same street can carry very different taxes. And remember Victor and other homes over the line in Ontario County use that county’s records, not Monroe’s.

Equalization rates in plain English

Not every town assesses at full market value. One town might assess homes at 100% of value, another at a fraction of it. The equalization rate is New York State’s measure of a municipality’s overall level of assessment: total assessed value divided by total market value.

Why should a buyer care? Two reasons. First, it explains why an assessment can look nothing like the price in towns that aren’t at full value. Second, if you ever want to challenge your assessment, you’ll need your town’s equalization rate or residential assessment ratio. Both are published by the state.

One caution: the rate is an average across a whole town, not a measure of any one house. It’s a way to understand the roll, not a home value tool.

Registering for STAR as a new buyer

STAR is New York’s School Tax Relief program. If you bought your home after 2015, you don’t get the old STAR exemption. You register with the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance for the STAR credit, and the state sends you the money directly.

• Who qualifies for Basic STAR: you own the home, it’s your primary residence, and the combined income of the owners and their spouses who live there is $500,000 or less.
• Enhanced STAR: a larger benefit for qualifying homeowners 65 and older, with a lower income limit set by the state each year.
• How to register: online through the Tax Department’s Homeowner Benefit Portal at tax.ny.gov/star, or by phone at 518-457-2036.
• What to have ready: names and Social Security numbers for all owners and their spouses, your school district, the approximate purchase date, the sellers’ names, and your latest school tax bill if you have one.

Register soon after you close. It’s the easiest money you’ll get as a new homeowner, and people forget it in the chaos of moving.

How taxes are settled at closing

Each tax bill here covers a tax year, and when you close, at least some of those years are still running. So at closing, the attorneys split each current bill by date. If the seller already paid for time you’ll own the home, you reimburse them for those days. If a bill is due but unpaid, it’s handled the other way around.

Because the city, town, county and school bills each run on their own schedule, the adjustments depend on your closing date. You’ll see them as line items on your Closing Disclosure and on your attorney’s closing statement. Ask your attorney to walk you through them; it’s one of the most common “what is this?” lines.

Questions buyers ask

Sources

• City of Rochester property tax billing and installment dates: cityofrochester.gov
• City of Rochester property information portal: cityofrochester.gov/propinfo
• Monroe County Treasury tax calendar: monroecounty.gov
• Monroe County Real Property Portal: monroecounty.gov
• Monroe County town assessors and tax receivers: monroecounty.gov
• Monroe County tax rate tables: monroecounty.gov
• NYS Tax Department, equalization rates: tax.ny.gov
• NYS Tax Department, STAR eligibility and registration: tax.ny.gov/star and STAR eligibility
• NYS Tax Department, property tax exemptions: tax.ny.gov
• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Closing Disclosure: consumerfinance.gov

This guide is general information, not tax or legal advice. Confirm current dates and rates with the City, your town and Monroe County, and ask your attorney or a tax professional about your situation.

Related: Buying in the City of Rochester · Buying in Greece · What you need to close · All guides